It's a nice thing when a missing sound comes back after a long absence. I am a big fan of Mouth by Mouth-era His Name Is Alive (before the band took on a completely different form.) In fact, that LP is probably my most-listened-to release, as far as last.fm is concerned, next to the Magnetic Fields' 69 Love Songs.
Anyhow, I picked up Selebrities new LP Delusions, and the HNIA sound was there. It's not completely 1:1, but that in itself is a good thing. Enjoy!